Published Thursday, October 19, 2000, in the Miami Herald

Senate passes embargo bill

BY ANA RADELAT
Special to The Herald

The Senate gave final congressional approval Wednesday to a $78 billion farm spending bill that modestly eases the trade embargo against Cuba, ending a bitter months-long standoff and making both winners and losers of all the combatants.

The bill, approved 86-8, would allow the sale of food to Cuba for the first time in four decades, but is restricted because it bars the federal government or U.S. banks from financing the shipments.

Florida Sens. Bob Graham, a Democrat, and Connie Mack, a Republican, both voted in favor of the bill, which President Clinton is expected to sign.

Farm groups eager to trade with Cuba say the legislation is a start.

``Hopefully, it will be a step toward a broader opening,'' said Sen. Tim Hutchinson, an Arkansas Republican whose state's farmers hope to sell rice to Cuba.

Sean Garcia, executive director of the Cuban Committee for Democracy, said, ``Everybody got a little bit of something. We have won some, and lost some.''

Garcia said that the big win for the CCD, a 5,000-member exile group that supported easing food sanctions on Havana, is that ``for the first time proponents of the embargo have had their hold on the agenda irreparably broken.''

But Garcia cites as losses the deal's restrictions on sales to Cuba and the ``immediate setback'' posed by a provision in the agreement that strips the president of his power to expand U.S. travel to Cuba.

The restrictions on sales to Cuba and the travel freeze were hailed as big victories by Reps. Lincoln Díaz-Balart and Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, Miami Republicans.

In fact, for Díaz-Balart the compromise bill represented ``the most significant victory since I've been in Congress.''

Díaz-Balart said congressional fervor over making China a permanent preferential trade partner had created a free-trade ``tidal wave'' that threatened to sweep away the 40-year-old embargo -- and that was stopped. Moreover, Díaz-Balart was concerned that ``there would be a major Clinton initiative'' that would open up U.S. travel to Cuba.

Under the new legislation, Cuban President Fidel Castro's government would be required to pay for U.S. agricultural products in cash or through financing by foreign banks -- no U.S. private or government financing could be used. Havana has denounced the conditions as ``discriminatory and humiliating.''

But the agreement does not impose those restrictions on other nations affected by the deal -- North Korea, Libya, Sudan and Iran. To placate key farm state lawmakers who opposed the restrictions on Cuba, GOP leaders abandoned their insistence that sales to Iran carry the same restrictions as those to Cuba.

When Clinton signs the bill into law, the biggest winner will be U.S. agribusiness. Unfettered by the restrictions that apply to Cuba, U.S. banks can be involved in food sales to North Korea, Libya, Sudan -- as well as Iran, potentially a much bigger market than Cuba.

``There's a real possibility that there will be big sales to Iran,'' said Mary Kay Thatcher, a lobbyist with the American Farm Bureau Federation.

Cuban American National Foundation Executive Vice President Dennis Hays said his anti-Castro group preferred the status quo.

``Our position was, that if nothing at all happened, that's good,'' Hays said.

In addition, Hays worried that the momentum to ease the embargo has not been halted.

``The agriculture guys will try to create a market in Cuba, they'll lobby Congress to allow [U.S.] tourism to Cuba. They'll say `we've got to give them tourists or who will buy our chicken parts,' '' Hays said.

Pressure to remove at the restrictions on the sale of food and medicine to Cuba peaked in this session of Congress because American farm groups and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce stepped up an anti-sanctions drive.

The result was an agreement brokered between Republicans seeking new markets for their farmers and GOP congressional leaders intent on keeping the embargo intact.

A deal was needed because the dispute over Cuba had for months blocked progress on the huge agriculture appropriations bill.

The House approved the farm bill last week with a 340-75 vote.

This report was supplemented by Herald wire services.

Copyright 2000 the Miami Herald.
Republished here with the permission of the Miami Herald. No further republication or redistribution is permitted without the written approval of The Miami Herald.